How the Model T drove hats out of fashion

Last week, I came across this tweet from an account I follow on Twitter.

Take a closer look at the picture.

Every single person in this picture, man or woman, was wearing a hat. There isn’t a single person in that picture that isn’t wearing a hat. People even wore broad-rimmed and Panama hats to the beach (unless they were swimming).

Of course, createstreets was pointing out the large sidewalks and tiny roads in the picture, reminding the audience that this was at a time when everybody was walking or riding a horse, and very few people drove cars.

I’m not really sure how my train of thought ended up where it did, but I quickly asked this question: did hats fall out of fashion because of cars?

I ended up getting into a conversation with Andrew, who previously worked in the fashion world, about this particular subject, and after a little bit of research, here’s what I found:

Everyone wore hats, and I mean everyone. Men, women, kids. Hats were generally worn in the streets, but not indoors. They protected people from the sun and rain, and were much easier to carry compared to umbrellas or parasols, which had existed for almost two thousand years by the beginning of the 20th century. While umbrellas had evolved to become very lightweight, they were still too large to carry around, which was a hassle when the most common form of transportation was walking. Pocket umbrellas weren’t even invented until the late 1920s, and many stores had already offered umbrellas for rent when customers were caught in a downpour.

Hats had already been worn for thousands of years by the time the Model T was introduced, but the styles and fashion changed over the years. Different hats signaled different statuses and wealth, and everyone wore them from the Chinese to the Arabs, the French to the Nigerians, and many more. So, how did the Model T suddenly wipe them out of everyday fashion?

Henry Ford first introduced the Model T in 1908, and began selling the cars in 1909. The original Model T contained a foldable vinyl roof that was designed based on horse-driven carriages. In its first year, the Ford Motor Company (FMC) only sold about 10,000 Model Ts*, and compared to the population of the United States at the beginning of the 20th century (~72 million), it was a very small and insignificant number. Ford needed to prove that producing cars for the masses was possible and, more importantly, profitable. How were he and the FMC ever going to produce enough cars for millions of people?

That answer came in the form of the assembly line. Ford was approached by one of the company’s production managers, William Klann, with an idea that could potentially speed up vehicle production and drive down costs. Taking inspiration from a disassembly line in a Chicago butcher’s shop, where animals were put on a conveyer belt and butchers were each assigned to cut a specific part, Klann proposed a similar approach in reverse to assemble vehicles. By assigning each worker a specific part to assemble on every car that came through the line, jobs became more specialized and increased efficiency, speeding up the development process and reducing the costs it took to train employees.

The assembly line worked. By 1916, the Model T cost $360, down from its original price of $825, and the company was producing over half a million cars annually. The FMC proved to the rest of the world that it was possible to mass-produce cars. The biggest impact on production was that the assembly line reduced cost per unit (CPU), and this not only guaranteed the company profits as the price of the vehicle went down, but the average FMC worker could afford to buy a car with a modest salary of $5 per day. This proved to be a very effective marketing strategy for Ford, and the automobile itch spread like wildfire. Not only were consumers lining up to buy the cars, but other car companies were copying the assembly line. The FMC had already owned half the American market, but by the 1920s, over 27 million Ford cars had been sold, one for every three Americans. Now, the question remains—how did this affect hats?

Ford Model T Centennial - 1926 Model T Assembly ...

Prior to the mass production of cars, walking was the main source of short-distance transportation. Carriages were commonly used for medium distances within a city, and trains were for long-distance travel. Commercial aviation didn’t exist for long-distance travel until just before the start of the Great Depression, and didn’t really take off until after the end of World War II. Because people didn’t need to travel far and often, they stayed within their city and traveled by foot every day, and because they were traveling by foot, they were under the sun all day long and needed something to cover their heads. Hats were a no-brainer.

Hats in fashion hit their peak around the 1920s, and set on a downhill path from there. At the same time, the FMC was able to flood the market with their Model Ts and almost completely dominate the American car market. Cars were widespread and used for everyday travel, taking people off of their feet and into cars with vinyl roofs (the steel roof was later applied in the mid-1930s). People suddenly realized that they really didn’t need hats inside their cars. They could go from house to car and from car to work. The car’s roof protected drivers and passengers from all kinds of weather. Why did they need to wear hats anymore?

Of course, the Great Depression and WWII immediately followed the 1920s, and I would argue this might have slowed the death of hats in fashion, at least for men. Women had already begun to phase hats out of everyday fashion in the 1930s, and hats were out of the norm by the 1940s. Men had interestingly delayed phasing out hats by almost a decade, and this might have been due to the large population of males who went to serve in the war. Hats and caps were standard in uniforms, and the older generation was already used to it. Young boys at home grew up around women (and a few men) that, although working towards the war effort, didn’t wear hats as part of everyday fashion. Paired with the Greaser subculture that hit American youth in the 40s and 50s, hats were quickly accelerated out of male fashion.

Hats aren’t all the way dead. We see snapbacks all the time, but that revival didn’t really happen until the 1980s and 90s with the rise of hip-hop and rap. While hip-hop helped bring hats back into fashion, it wasn’t to the same degree as hats pre-Model T. People are now dependent on cars more than ever before. They serve as short-, medium-, and long-distance transportation. Los Angeles was built on the assumption that everyone had cars. Why would anyone ever go back to a life where cars didn’t exist?


* Refers to Ford’s fiscal year (October 1, 1908 to September 30, 1909).

17 thoughts on “How the Model T drove hats out of fashion

  1. Pingback: Thursday assorted links - Marginal REVOLUTION

  2. ILostMyHat

    I will add another theory that, chronologically, meshes well with the introduction and popularization of the car: the popularization of tanning. Tanning first began to become fashionable in European countries, and then America, in the 1920s as the sun became less associated among the fashionable set with hard labor and more with leisure. Thus, by the end of the 1940s and the start of the post-war era, having fair skin was no longer a sign of wealth and leisure, as it had been in the 18th and 19th centuries: now, having a tan was a sign you were rich and had enough and had enough extra time to lay about in the sun, or to take vacations to sunny places. If you look at a lot of post-war advertising, especially featuring men, you can see this: all the guys are “tall, dark, and handsome.” Given that hats shade your face and prevent getting a nice, even bronzed tone, it’s no wonder that they fell out of favor.

    Like

    Reply
  3. Kdot

    This was interesting. Thanks for sharing.

    One note, re: “Why would anyone ever go back to a life where cars didn’t exist?“

    Answers can be found in some other things I notice from that picture:
    – no overweight folks
    – people talking with others along their commutes

    Like

    Reply
    1. lamaalrajih Post author

      Thank you for reading! Haha, yes, that was meant to be more of a rhetorical question. A lot of health problems can be attributed to cars and motorized vehicles (not just pollution, but also lack of exercise, road rage, etc). I will add that the invention of the chair probably caused more problems than that, though.

      Like

      Reply
  4. Pingback: Why did hats lose their popularity? – Detroit Pub

  5. pnow

    Interesting theory.
    At the same time was the emergence of the film industry. People would have regularly seen indoor scenes of actors and actresses with fashionable hairstyles and makeup. Which is something initially women would have copied to try to look like glamorous film stars of the twenties and thirties, and men would have copied later, probably to look like music stars. Difficult to wear an Elvis or Beatles style haircut if you keep putting on and taking off a hat.

    Like

    Reply
  6. Pingback: Weekly Link Love—Edition 19 – mrbillbrazil

  7. Pingback: Weekly Link Love—Edition 19 – readly.info

  8. Pingback: Weekly Link Love—Edition 19 | Top Beauty Stories

  9. Pingback: Weekly Link Love—Edition 19 | Healthy Not Crazy

  10. Pingback: Weekly Link Love—Edition 19 – Sortiwa Trending Viral News Portal

  11. Pingback: Weekly Hyperlink Love—Version 19 | Mark's Each day Apple | Naturally Healthy Life

  12. Pingback: Weekly Link Love—Edition 19 – Fitness Badass

  13. Pingback: Weekly Link Love—Edition 19 - Keto4Energy

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s